• Home
  • Ethical Fund Ratings
  • Find An Adviser
    • NSW
    • ACT
    • QLD
    • VIC
    • SA
    • TAS
    • WA
    • NT
    • New Zealand
  • Ethical Investment Week
    • Events
  • Resources
    • Ethical Investment Guide
    • What is Ethical Investment?
    • 2021 Annual Report
    • Education
    • FAQs
    • Performance
    • Media
    • Videos
    • Interviews
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • For Advisers
  • Archive Blogs
Ethical Advisers' Co-op
  • Home
  • Ethical Fund Ratings
  • Find An Adviser
    • NSW
    • ACT
    • QLD
    • VIC
    • SA
    • TAS
    • WA
    • NT
    • New Zealand
  • Ethical Investment Week
    • Events
  • Resources
    • Ethical Investment Guide
    • What is Ethical Investment?
    • 2021 Annual Report
    • Education
    • FAQs
    • Performance
    • Media
    • Videos
    • Interviews
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • For Advisers
  • Archive Blogs

Ethical Advisers' Blog

Ethical Financial Advice

28/11/2018

 
Terry Pinnell
Ethical Investment Advisers

In the Banking Royal Commission Ken Henry of the NAB said that the capitalism is about “businesses have no responsibility other than to maximise profits to shareholders.’’

Over the years when I have talked with Trustees of supers and fund managers they have all told me that boards should be focused on the maximisation of profits for shareholders.

In the Banking Royal Commission it appears that Rowena Orr is suggesting to the banks that profit shouldn’t come at the expense of mistreated customers. The argument probably would run that by ripping off customers the short-term interests of shareholders are considered, but possibly not in the long-term interests.

But it appears that the banks did not put their customers before profits and certainly not before bonuses. For the banks customers are seen cash cows to pay shareholder profits, rather than the customer being the focus of good products and service.
 
Terry Pinnell
Ethical Investment Advisers

In the Banking Royal Commission Ken Henry of the NAB said that the capitalism is about “businesses have no responsibility other than to maximise profits to shareholders.’’

Over the years when I have talked with Trustees of supers and fund managers they have all told me that boards should be focused on the maximisation of profits for shareholders.

In the Banking Royal Commission it appears that Rowena Orr is suggesting to the banks that profit shouldn’t come at the expense of mistreated customers. The argument probably would run that by ripping off customers the short-term interests of shareholders are considered, but possibly not in the long-term interests.

But it appears that the banks did not put their customers before profits and certainly not before bonuses. For the banks customers are seen cash cows to pay shareholder profits, rather than the customer being the focus of good products and service. 

In financial planning there is what is called a Safe Harbour Checklist and it is obvious to all who have watched the Banks and AMP answer questions that the Checklist was never used. The checklist says that the adviser should:

  1. Identify the objectives, financial situation and needs of the client that were disclosed by the client through instructions. 
  2. Identify the subject matter sought by the client (whether explicitly or implicitly); 
  3. Identify the objectives, financial situation and needs of the client (reasonably  considered relevant to the advice sought) on that subject matter (ie client’s relevant circumstances); 
  4. If reasonably apparent information relating to the client’s relevant circumstances is incomplete or inaccurate, make reasonable inquiries to obtain complete and accurate information. 
  5. Assess whether you as the advice provider has the expertise required to provide the client with advice on the subject matter sought and, if not, decline to provide the advice. 
  6. Reasonably consider recommending a financial product by conducting a reasonable investigation into the financial products that might achieve the objectives and meet the clients needs reasonably considered relevant to advice subject matter; and assess the information gathered in the investigation.
  7. Base all judgements in advising the client on the client’s relevant circumstances.
  8. Take any other step that, at the time the advice is provided, would reasonably be regarded as being in the best interests of the client, given the client’s relevant circumstances.

The Checklist is in Section 961B(2) of the Corporations Act and the advice provider should be able to prove that the checklist has been followed (this is also set out in Section 175 of the ASIC regulations.) 

As an ethical adviser you would also add to the checklist the clients ethics and values, consider your conflicts of interest and the transparency and fairness of your fee disclosure.

Client’s ethics and values are often overlooked by main stream advisers as unnecessary to give good advice, but values play a huge part of most peoples’ lives and to integrate their investment choices with client values seems to me to be mandatory.

The discussion that is brought up when talking about values and ethics gives the adviser a much deeper idea of their client and what makes them tick. It also helps to cement the client adviser relationship, because who wants to invest with an adviser who has a completely different set of values

In our practice we try to run what I would call social capitalism, where to paraphrase Adam Smith “That profit is a by product of customer satisfaction.”

Comments are closed.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    July 2019
    June 2019
    March 2019
    November 2018
    July 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017

© Ethical Advisers' Co-operative Limited 2022

​The contents of this website are intended as general advice only.  The information provided by the Ethical Advisers Co-operative do not account for any individual’s personal objectives, financial situation or needs. It should not be used, relied upon, or treated as a substitute for specific professional advice.  The Ethical Advisers Co-operative recommends all users obtain their own independent professional advice from an appropriately qualified financial adviser before making any decision relating to their particular requirements or circumstances. Investing in, or switching between investments or superannuation funds may have unintended financial consequences. 
 
The survey results, and all information contained in this website including all documents, consider only the ethics of each fund and do not include any analysis of fees, performance or financial suitability. The ethical score is subjective and benchmarked against each adviser’s average ethical client. Your ethics may differ. We recommend you speak to an experienced ethical financial adviser for personalised advice before making any decisions. The information provided by the Ethical Advisers Co-operative does not constitute financial advice. The information is presented in order to inform people motivated by ethical, environmental or social concerns. 

Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Ethical Fund Ratings
  • Find An Adviser
    • NSW
    • ACT
    • QLD
    • VIC
    • SA
    • TAS
    • WA
    • NT
    • New Zealand
  • Ethical Investment Week
    • Events
  • Resources
    • Ethical Investment Guide
    • What is Ethical Investment?
    • 2021 Annual Report
    • Education
    • FAQs
    • Performance
    • Media
    • Videos
    • Interviews
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • For Advisers
  • Archive Blogs